Did It Have To Be Her?

I left a present for you underneath your pillowcase
You went to New York and got me to check in on your place
Called me up every day, said that you're having a great time
Forgot to say, she was right there by your side
Now looking back I wasn't crazy when I asked if everything's okay

Can't you see the similarities?
Same brown hair just a different city
So convenient that we're the same
And she's even got my name

Did you really have to go and break my heart with someone just like me?
Did you ever think of how you'd fuck me up with insecurity?
And I keep on trying but not a part of me is okay
If you're gonna tell me something
Tell me this
Did it have to be her?
Did it have to be her?

I can't escape the feeling that I'm just not good enough
Cause in two weeks you threw away four years of all my love
Now you're begging for me but you feel like a stranger
Every sorry doesn't change that you're a traitor
Wish I could put you in my body so you feel every pain I feel

Can't you see the similarities?
Same brown hair just a different city
So convenient that we're the same
And she's even got my name

Did you really have to go and break my heart with someone just like me?
Did you ever think of how you'd fuck me up with insecurity?
And I keep on trying but not a part of me is okay
If you're gonna tell me something
Tell me this
Did it have to be her?

Did her touch make you feel like you ever did with mine?
Did the guilt eat you up or did you push it out your mind?
I guess you never had to worry about getting us confused
Cause if you called me by her name
I wouldn't have a clue

Did you really have to go and break my heart with someone just like me?
Did you ever think of how you'd fuck me up with insecurity?
And I keep on trying but not a part of me is okay
If you're gonna tell me something
Tell me this
Did it have to be her?
Did it have to be her?