Overplayed

I thought I heard you laugh in my car
'Cause I played our song, but she sang your favorite part
For a minute I thought it was you
And I wish it was, to tell you the truth

Now I sleep over on weekends, her dad lets me stay
I jump in the pool first so she can feel safe
I know we said forever, but now forever's gone away

'Cause you said you'd rather be alone
And that's just how it goes
We were better than what movies say
But now our story's overplayed, played

What do you do when you hear our song?
Do you listen and cry?
Or do you quickly turn it off?
I wish sometimes you'd tell me that you're sorry
I wish I was next to you
And I shouldn't be texting you

Now I sleep over on weekends, her dad lets me stay
I jump in the pool first so she can feel safe
I know we said forever, but now forever's gone away

'Cause you said you'd rather be alone
And that's just how it goes
We were better than what movies say
But now our story's overplayed, played

The photos, the memories
I can't believe they're killing me
I'm sorry you're sorry
But where are we?
Your necklace, my T-shirt
Your eyes when you told me this won't hurt
Where are we?
Where are we?
Where are we?

Now I sleep over on weekends, her dad lets me stay
I jump in the pool first so she can feel safe
I know we said forever, but now forever's gone away
You said you had to be alone
And that's just how it goes