Why, Oh, Why?

(album: We Couldn't Think Of A Title! - 2003)

I'm looking at you after it's all over
And I don't feel quite the same
That look in your eyes says you don't want me anymore
Even though you are to blame

Why, oh, why did this have to happen
Why did you do me this way

Tell me why
You had to lead me on so long
Tell me why
I had to end it all in song
Tell me why
You ran away with my best friend
Tell me why
I still love you
Love you

Love

I came across an old love letter
And here's what you had to say
Please pick up a gallon of milk while you're shopping at the store

You said I love you so
You're everything to me
I could love no other one
Yeah right

Except for maybe like I said my best friend
And my brother and my dad
And my other brother
And his best friend
And that guy's brother as well
And that one guy who used to come over and mow the lawn every Saturday
Who had a cool tattoo of a dragon on his shoulder and it was really neat and stuff

Tell me why
You slept with everyone but me
Tell me why
I'm out of words that rhyme with me
Tell me why
You still owe me three bucks for that milk
Tell me why
I still love you

Why
Did you leave me alone
Why
In the cold
In the darkness
Why
So I could talk to the walls in the basement
Why
Did you hurt me so bad
Why
Did you feel the remorse
Why
When you broke both of my shins with a crowbar

Tell me why
I still love you
Even though you're a bitch
I still love you
Even though you're a psycho
I still love you
Even though you should die
I still love you